November 27, 2023
Nonprofit Technology & Fundraising Blog
Subscribe to our mailing list
Subscribe to our mailing list
Congratulations! Break out the champagne. Today’s #GivingTuesday looks to be your best ever! Make those new donors feel engaged with an email welcome series. We’ll show you how to keep them coming back!
New financial commitments to your organization are extremely rare and precious. Yet, all too often, these new donors never return to make a second gift.
Roger Craven, in his book Retention Fundraising, lists seven factors that influence donor retention:
Of course it’s important to reach out and personally thank each donor, making them just feel that their gift matters.One of the easiest ways to do this is with an email welcome series.
An email welcome series is a series of email campaigns designed to welcome new donors, lower donor remorse, and nurture additional engagement. They consist of a series of messages delivered over a specific timeframe.
The technical steps for creating a welcome series vary depending upon the email marketing software you use, but generally follow these steps:
Decide what your goals are for welcoming donors. Do you want new donors to share the campaign with their friends? Do you want folks who create a peer-to-peer fundraising page to get the most out of their fundraiser? Do you want them to like your Facebook Page?
In a welcome series, your audience is pretty clear: people who just made a donation. However, this audience may include:
As you can imagine, the email messages should speak to each specific relationship. The more you can personalize the messaging to the audience, the more likely you’ll retain that donor.
Decide on the frequency and number of messages. You have to strike a balance between reminding them about upcoming campaigns, and being too pushy.
Your message frequency will depend on what actions you want people to take after they make that first, second, or monthly gift.
Write the messages in advance, and base them on your understanding of what motivates your segments/personas.
Keep them super-short and written in the second-person, as if you’re writing to a friend. Read this post on email marketing for more tips on writing more effective email messages. And don’t forget to write awesome subject lines!
The next step is to create segmentation rules for each audience. Constant Contact lets you add tags to subscribers, which is the best approach. This way, you can create more personalized email campaigns. For example, repeat donors should receive an initial message that acknowledges their prior support.
After you’re written your messages and subject lines, enter them into your email marketing tool.
In terms of how the drip part of all this works, the timing of your messages is typically kicked off when someone makes a donation. The first messages should be sent immediately and should remind the donor of their impact. The following messages vary depending on your goals (sharing the campaign, joining your social community, making another gift, etc).
You’ll want to start tracking open rates, click-through rates, conversions and other stats important to determine the effectiveness of your welcome series.
The data you gather from day one will help you avoid unintended disasters by adjusting the messaging and frequency, leading to more happy donors.
Use these steps to design your own automated welcome series in Constant Contact. Sign up for a free trial today!
About John Haydon: Trainer, coach, consultant, speaker, and author of Facebook Marketing for Dummies, John Haydon is one of the most sought-after digital marketing experts for nonprofits and charities. Learn more at www.johnhaydon.com